Technology and Engineering Atlas

How Things Are Built
Sign In
Text size
100%
Theme
Open Question

Berg, Lobban, or Cohen and Boyer: who deserves primary credit for recombinant DNA?

Open Question

Peter Lobban first proposed the idea of recombinant DNA as a Stanford graduate student, Paul Berg's laboratory produced the first recombinant DNA molecule around 1971-72 and Berg later won a Nobel Prize partly for this work, yet the 1974 United States patent on recombinant DNA technology names only Stanley Cohen and Herbert Boyer as inventors, for a related but distinct gene-cloning technique published in 1973.

What would resolve this A settled historical or legal consensus on whether patent inventorship (Cohen and Boyer's cloning technique) or first scientific priority (Lobban's proposal and Berg's molecule) is the correct measure of who invented recombinant DNA would resolve the dispute.
OpenHistory of biotechnology and biological engineeringRecombinant DNA (Wikipedia)
Connections

Question On

Source Recombinant DNA (Wikipedia)
Sources
Recombinant DNA (Wikipedia)
Wikimedia FoundationHistory section, first paragraph
Quote, History section, first paragraph
The idea of recombinant DNA was first proposed by Peter Lobban, a graduate student of Prof. Dale Kaiser in the Biochemistry Department at Stanford University Medical School. The first publications describing the successful production and intracellular replication of recombinant DNA appeared in 1972 and 1973, from Stanford and UCSF.
View the Source
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.