Open Question

Who deserves credit for inventing the miners' safety lamp: Humphry Davy, honored by the Royal Society in 1815, or George Stephenson, who devised his own lamp independently the same year?

Open Question

Humphry Davy presented his safety lamp design to the Royal Society in London on 9 November 1815 and was awarded the society's Rumford Medal and two thousand pounds worth of silver. Engine-wright George Stephenson demonstrated his own, independently devised safety lamp down Killingworth Colliery a month before Davy's presentation, but his lamp was not developed and publicly credited until after Davy's paper, leading Davy to accuse him of theft.

What would resolve this An 1833 House of Commons committee found that Stephenson had an equal claim to inventing the safety lamp, yet Davy went to his grave insisting Stephenson had stolen his idea; no single verdict has ever definitively settled priority between the two men.
OpenHistory of TechnologyWikipedia contributors, Davy Lamp (Wikipedia)
Connections

Question On

Source Davy Lamp (Wikipedia)Wikipedia contributors
Sources
Davy Lamp (Wikipedia)
Wikipedia contributors, Wikimedia FoundationHistory section, Stephenson priority dispute paragraph
Quote, History section, Stephenson priority dispute paragraph
A local committee of enquiry gathered in support of Stephenson exonerated him, showing that he had been working separately to create the Geordie lamp, and raised a subscription for him of £1,000. Davy and his supporters refused to accept their findings, and would not see how an uneducated man such as Stephenson could come up with the solution he had: Stephenson himself freely admitted that he had arrived at a practical solution on the basis of an erroneous theory. In 1833, a House of Commons committee found that Stephenson had equal claim to having invented the safety lamp. Davy went to his grave claiming that Stephenson had stolen his idea.
View the Source
Comments (0)
No comments yet. Be the first to share a thought.
Reader Challenges (0)
No disputes yet. Spotted an error or a better source? Open the first one.

Technology and Engineering Atlas

How Things Are Built
Sign In
Text size
100%
Theme